Welcome to Geeklog, Anonymous Sunday, December 22 2024 @ 07:10 pm EST
Geeklog Forums
GeeLog versus PHPNuke
SagaLore
Anonymous
Please don't scold me, please be honest. 
Many months back I tried out GeekLog after trying out Nucleus. I really liked GeekLog's ability to modularize the content columns, and read RSS.
I haven't tried PHPNuke, but I know that's another popular CMS system. I have seen posts here of people porting from PHPN to GL, and vice versa.
So what advantages/strength do each have? Weaknesses?
I just want to be sure I go with the right one for my needs.
thanks
Many months back I tried out GeekLog after trying out Nucleus. I really liked GeekLog's ability to modularize the content columns, and read RSS.
I haven't tried PHPNuke, but I know that's another popular CMS system. I have seen posts here of people porting from PHPN to GL, and vice versa.
So what advantages/strength do each have? Weaknesses?
I just want to be sure I go with the right one for my needs.
thanks
11
10
Quote
Status: offline
destr0yr
Forum User
Full Member
Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 324
Try www.opensourcecms.com, also here or here
-- destr0yr
"I love deadlines. I like the whooshing sound they make as they fly by." -- Douglas Adams
-- destr0yr
"I love deadlines. I like the whooshing sound they make as they fly by." -- Douglas Adams
15
16
Quote
Status: offline
Baleful
Forum User
Newbie
Registered: 05/14/04
Posts: 6
PHP-Nuke was the first CMS I ever tried. I liked it. Then I broke my site. Then did it again. Few more times. Few more CMS's,and now i'm on to GeekLog...
PHP-Nuke has an easier installation, you put the files in your root directory, tweak the config.php file, and run the install. Done.
Geeklog, on the other hand, directs you to put most of the files in a non web-accessible directory for security purposes. Then copy over only the needed files to the root web directory. Also a slightly more tedius installation.
I think GL looks neater, although Nuke probably has more themes, modules, hacks, blocks, etc. for it. GL seems to me to be a bit easier to administer...I've never looked into block/module/theme customization, as I only know HTML and VERY little PHP...
And for some reason, I have more users registered on my site (a whopping 10, and I only know who one of them is) then I ever did with PHP-Nuke, and I publicized my site more with Nuke (well, sort of...). My site still has the same stuff it did then, nothing much. Main difference between now and then is CMS, so maybe that's got something to do with it. I dont' know.
.:Let the Madness ensue:.
PHP-Nuke has an easier installation, you put the files in your root directory, tweak the config.php file, and run the install. Done.
Geeklog, on the other hand, directs you to put most of the files in a non web-accessible directory for security purposes. Then copy over only the needed files to the root web directory. Also a slightly more tedius installation.
I think GL looks neater, although Nuke probably has more themes, modules, hacks, blocks, etc. for it. GL seems to me to be a bit easier to administer...I've never looked into block/module/theme customization, as I only know HTML and VERY little PHP...
And for some reason, I have more users registered on my site (a whopping 10, and I only know who one of them is) then I ever did with PHP-Nuke, and I publicized my site more with Nuke (well, sort of...). My site still has the same stuff it did then, nothing much. Main difference between now and then is CMS, so maybe that's got something to do with it. I dont' know.
.:Let the Madness ensue:.
8
10
Quote
Status: offline
Robin
Forum User
Full Member
Registered: 02/15/02
Posts: 725
Quote by SagaLore:So what advantages/strength do each have?
What I can tell, one of many, many, many GL strengths is one very important i.e. SUPPORT. I haven't been left "alone" with my questions/issues etc. related to GL whenever I asked here in the Forum.
If you consider to use whatever package try the support first.
Geeklog's ROCKS
Geeklog Polish Support Team
25
12
Quote
Status: offline
noktuki
Forum User
Newbie
Registered: 05/10/04
Posts: 12
Quote by Robin:
What I can tell, one of many, many, many GL strengths is one very important i.e. SUPPORT. I haven't been left "alone" with my questions/issues etc. related to GL whenever I asked here in the Forum.
If you consider to use whatever package try the support first.
Geeklog's ROCKS
Quote by SagaLore:So what advantages/strength do each have?
What I can tell, one of many, many, many GL strengths is one very important i.e. SUPPORT. I haven't been left "alone" with my questions/issues etc. related to GL whenever I asked here in the Forum.
If you consider to use whatever package try the support first.
Geeklog's ROCKS
hear hear
IK!
9
11
Quote
All times are EST. The time is now 07:10 pm.
- Normal Topic
- Sticky Topic
- Locked Topic
- New Post
- Sticky Topic W/ New Post
- Locked Topic W/ New Post
- View Anonymous Posts
- Able to post
- Filtered HTML Allowed
- Censored Content